Is the knee defender legal?

Legality and Airline Policies on Knee Defenders

Knee defenders are devices used by airline passengers to prevent seat recline, ensuring personal comfort during flights. However, their legality and permissibility on aircraft are subject to airline discretion and regulations.

Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Stance

The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) does not explicitly prohibit or mandate the use of knee defenders. It maintains a neutral stance, leaving the decision to individual airlines.

Airline Policies

Airline policies on knee defenders vary widely. Some airlines, such as Southwest Airlines and Delta Air Lines, allow their use as long as they do not interfere with passenger safety or the operation of the aircraft. Others, such as United Airlines and American Airlines, prohibit their use altogether.

Passenger Comfort vs. Safety

The primary purpose of knee defenders is to prevent seat recline, which some passengers find uncomfortable or even painful. However, their use has also raised safety concerns. In the event of an emergency evacuation, knee defenders could obstruct the aisle and prevent passengers from exiting the aircraft quickly.

Legal Disputes

The use of knee defenders has occasionally led to disputes between passengers and airline staff. In some cases, passengers have been ordered to remove or surrender their knee defenders, leading to heated exchanges.

Conclusion

The legality and permissibility of knee defenders on aircraft depends on individual airline policies. Passengers should check with their carrier before using these devices to avoid potential conflicts or violations. While some passengers may find knee defenders to be useful for their personal comfort, it is important to prioritize safety and follow airline regulations.

Key Takeaways:

• The FAA maintains a neutral stance on knee defenders.
• Airline policies on knee defenders vary.
• Passengers should consult with their airline before using knee defenders.
• Knee defenders can provide comfort but also raise safety concerns.
• Disputes over knee defenders have occurred between passengers and airline staff.